Two SLS-Free Toothpastes, Different Textures
D.R. Harris offers two SLS-free toothpastes: a foam toothpaste and a gel toothpaste. Both skip sodium lauryl sulfate, a common foaming agent that can irritate sensitive mouths. The real difference lies in texture, flavor, and fluoride content.
The foam toothpaste comes in a natural strawberry flavor and contains sodium fluoride. The gel toothpaste has a natural bubblegum flavor and is fluoride-free. Your choice depends on whether you prefer a foamy or gel-like feel and whether you want fluoride.
Ingredients and Key Differences
- ® Foam Toothpaste - SLS-Free, Fluoride & Non-Fluoride Options: Foam toothpaste ingredients include Water, Glycerin, Sorbitol, Poloxamer 407, Xylitol, Natural Strawberry Flavor, Nanosilver, Potassium Sorbate, Stevioside, Citric Acid, Calcium Citrate, Sodium Fluoride. Contains sodium fluoride for cavity protection. The natural strawberry flavor and SLS-free formula suit those who prefer a mild taste and avoid irritants.

® Foam Toothpaste - SLS-Free, Fluoride & Non-Fluoride Options - ® Gel Toothpaste - SLS-Free, Fluoride & Non-Fluoride Options: Gel toothpaste ingredients include Water, Glycerin, Sorbitol, Poloxamer 407, Xylitol, Natural Bubblegum Flavor, Nanosilver, Potassium Sorbate, Stevioside, Citric Acid, Calcium Citrate. Fluoride-free formulation appeals to those who avoid fluoride. The natural bubblegum flavor and gel texture offer a different brushing experience.

® Gel Toothpaste - SLS-Free, Fluoride & Non-Fluoride Options
Foam vs Gel at a Glance
Both toothpastes are SLS-free and share a similar base of glycerin, sorbitol, xylitol, nanosilver, and natural sweeteners. The key trade-offs are texture, flavor, and fluoride.
- Texture: Foam toothpaste dispenses as a light foam that spreads easily. Gel toothpaste has a thicker, more traditional gel consistency that may feel more familiar.
- Flavor: Foam: natural strawberry. Gel: natural bubblegum. Both are mild and free from artificial flavors.
- Fluoride: Foam contains sodium fluoride for cavity prevention. Gel is fluoride-free.
- Price: Foam toothpaste is $7.93 (catalog comparison price $13.00). Gel toothpaste is $9.23 (catalog comparison price $13.00). The gel is slightly more expensive.
Which One Should You Choose?
If you want fluoride for cavity protection and prefer a light, foamy texture with a strawberry flavor, the foam toothpaste is the straightforward choice. It's also the more affordable option.
If you avoid fluoride—perhaps due to personal preference or dietary reasons—and enjoy a gel texture with a bubblegum taste, the gel toothpaste fits that need. Note that the gel is fluoride-free, so it does not provide the same cavity-fighting benefit as the foam version.
Both formulas are SLS-free, making them gentle on sensitive gums and suitable for daily use. Neither contains artificial sweeteners or harsh detergents. Your decision ultimately comes down to fluoride preference and which texture and flavor you find more pleasant.


